Review – BATWOMAN #34

10583788_730299787043880_1140770535_n

The anticipation of this issue of BATWOMAN was definitely felt with full force. The heart shattering story has now ended with a crushing sense of reality. Kate leaves Maggie and turns to her darker side, embracing the night under the false glamour of a vampiric gaze.

10602626_730299623710563_254323561_nNothing will prepare you for the sadness of this issue. It was not only emotionally damaging but tore the only “happy” relationship in the Bat family to pieces. Marc Andreyko has unfortunately tarnished the end of these lovers, having Kate cowardly pick up and leave her fiancé with nothing more than a note. Highly out of character, the sliding scale of Kate’s behaviour only becomes worse as she steps out of the strong bold BATWOMAN and into the shadow of what she really was. The sloppy story writing does nothing for the open ended scenario that is unfolding into the FUTURES END arc. It’s a highly disappointing finish to a beloved relationship that so many fans have followed since the reboot of the 52 and only leaves us asking more questions than we have answers too.

10602664_730299757043883_1048505145_nWith more amateurish antics from the villains, the entire story is just a means to an end. They were rushed onto the scene with no real point or purpose, only to now have Kate shoved into the arms of another woman who is another D grade villain. Since the end of the annual, everything has been pushed out simply to culminate in this stunted ending, cheapening the once highly intellectual integrity of the series. None of the events since then have flowed, leaving both characters and the plot line lost to obscurity. The comic that had won awards for its debut is a far cry from the blaze of glory it had once been.

Positives10615723_730299880377204_1919956499_n

The artwork is still so beautiful with our female forms still intact. The flowing lines and bright colors with smooth contrasts fill each panel strongly.  Jeremy Haun really does know how to draw a strong woman without looking like a man all the time. I am also looking forward to return of a lost BATWOMAN character, but I won’t spoil that surprise, you will just have to wait till October to find out who “she” is.

Negatives

10580529_730299533710572_1898229005_nBATWOMAN would have never allowed her mask to have been ripped off her face so carelessly. It was a cheap shot, a faltering mistake no member of the Bat family would commit. Their masks are their identity and it was an insult to her will and drive contradicting everything she stands for. Marc Andreyko’s lack of respect to the readers and their loyalty to the series is a clear indication of his neglect to the characters and the relationship they held. The relationship has been a target since the pervious writers left, and finally the arrow was fired to hit the mark. Eloquent writing that was both witty and uplifting has now become diluted drivel. Fizzling out to disordered chatter of disjointed conversations and jumps in time that make no sense. It is abrasive to the readers and gives no closure on the path that BATWOMAN is tumbling down.

Verdict

If you love BATWOMAN and her relationship, DON’T read this issue. This is the end of a very long saga and will only leave a void that you won’t be able to fill. If you do chose the ending however, make sure you have plenty of tissues and a decent chocolate bar because you’re going to need it.

10609380_730299903710535_601484149_n

Rating

rating1outof5

  • jpowers55

    I’ll be so happy when Batwoman gets another writer. It may be too late to overturn the damage thats been done with the character since Williams left.

    • Renee Maria Montoya

      I feel like this writer just pissed all over rucka’s amazing writing and turned rich characters into 2d messes! I really cried for her and Maggie

      • jpowers55

        Hey dont forget about JH Williams.

        • SeeJay the WeeJay

          Blackman and Williams’s run was awful, though. The plots were bland and all hit pretty much the exact same beats, the dialogue was uninteresting, the pacing was terrible, and the characterization was really two-dimensional. They pissed all over the good work Rucka did for the character. Great art can’t make up for bad writing.

          And honestly? I had high hopes for Andreyko. After the shoddy Zero Year tie-in, he really started mopping up Blackman and Williams’s piss by making Kate and Maggie’s dialogue a lot more interesting and entertaining. Even better, he actually wrote a story that wasn’t a carbon copy of Elegy, and the idea of Batwoman and the Unknowns was incredibly exciting.

          …But after this pigshit? Wow. No. Fuck him too.

          • Ниссику

            Oh boy, another one. Let me guess – you also like Harley Queen ongoing? You know, I have a talk right now with another Andreyko lover, and after I showed him a lot of examples of Andreyko’s bad writing and Haun’s bad art, he keep telling me, that I have “wrong perspective”. Yeah, sure – when you start seeing bad writing, bad art, wasted characters, awful dialogues as something good, it’s the mysterious “right perspective”. :/ Bullcrap. Andreyko’s run is horroble, while Williams’s and Rucka’s was great. And you sir have no good taste. I’m sayng that, because I KNOW that Andreyko’s run is a piece of garbage, and if you like garbage that means you have a bad taste.

  • Ниссику

    Well, can’t say I didn’t saw it coming. Whole Andreyko’s run is a piece of garbage. Sad.

  • Michael Singer

    To be fair, Andreyko was dealt a REALLY bad hand. Breaking up Kate and Maggie was clearly an editorial mandate. Dan Didio essentially said as much with his “all superheroes must have crappy home lives in order to TRULLY be superheroes” comments. So ANY writer that came on the book would likely have had to deal with this issue as well. That doesn’t excuse the really unsatisfying way that it was handled, or the downright disturbing implications (and not in a good way) implications of “that scene.” It’s just that Andreyko isn’t solely to blame for this, DC editorial set the ground rules and writers have to adhere to them.